Ethics and Land Use Behavior Essay

Exclusively available on IvyPanda Available only on IvyPanda

Introduction

Ethics refers to a code of conduct that defines how individuals should behave or interact with others and the surrounding environment (MacKinnon 15). The code of conduct is informed by the principles of right (good) and wrong (evil).

We will write a custom essay on your topic a custom Essay on Ethics and Land Use Behavior
808 writers online

Engaging in ethical behavior involves making a choice between what is deemed to be right or wrong. An ethical individual must be able to distinguish right from wrong, as well as, good from evil. Furthermore, the individual must make a commitment to do only what is right or good (MacKinnon 18). Making ethical decisions is often difficult due to the values and attitudes that are held by individuals.

Moreover, the professional, economic and social contexts in which a person operates can challenge his ability to pursue ethical goals. In this paper, a distinction will be made between right and wrong behaviors in the context of land usage. This distinction will be underpinned by the premise that an ethical individual must do what is right to do rather than what he has a right to do.

Land Use Behavior

In most communities, individuals have competing values that create difficulties and contentions in the process of making land use decisions. Generally, land ethic is used as a principle for prioritizing the possible uses of the available land.

Concisely, it helps community members and decision-makers to select the right land use behaviors. In this regard, we can identify what is right or wrong in regard to land use by considering the following principles. First, protecting the interests of the less fortunate in the community should be the main objective of land use policies.

According to the principle of distributive justice, each member of the community should have access to a piece of land (MacKinnon 78). In the contrary, the rich tends to be the owners of large tracks of land, whereas the poor are usually squatters in most societies. In this regard, owning large tracks of land is wrong if such ownership denies majority of the community members the opportunity to acquire a piece of land. This is because the ownership serves self interest at the expense of the society.

Sharing the piece of land with other community members through mechanisms such as selling or nationalization will be the right behavior. For instance, in Zimbabwe the government nationalized part of the land that was owned by white settlers in order to resettle its citizens. This decision was justified by the fact that most citizens were squatters, whereas the white settlers owned over 60% of the country’s land. Hence, the government’s objective was to ensure distributive justice in land use.

1 hour!
The minimum time our certified writers need to deliver a 100% original paper

Second, land use policy must focus on protecting individuals’ right to a clean environment, as well as, preservation of natural ecosystems. This objective is yet to be achieved in most societies, especially, in the developed world.

The emergence of property rights movement was accompanied by a belief that the main obligation of a person is to protect personal gains without taking into account the effects of individual actions in the community. This belief is partly responsible for the reluctance among land users to take responsibility for their actions.

For example, industrial producers usually discharge untreated wastes into the ambient environment. This happens because the producers are interested in maximizing profits by avoiding the cost of controlling pollution. Similarly, real estate developers in the US have strategically chosen to construct very large houses in order to attract wealthy clients (Wotapka). However, their actions lead to the destruction of vegetation and ecosystems in the community.

Even though the producers and property developers have a right to invest, their behaviors are wrong since they infringe the public’s right to a clean environment. Land ethic calls for responsible investments (Brassard 497-500). According to the principle of culpability, individuals or institutions that are causing land use harms must be held accountable for their actions.

Concisely, they must be forced through social pressure or statutory provisions such as pollution tax to internalize the damage costs that are associated with their actions. Thus, the right behavior involves treating industrial wastes that might harm the environment. Similarly, property development should minimize land usage. For instance, constructing high rise apartments rather than bungalows is a socially responsible behavior in communities where land is scarce.

Third, land management structures must eliminate conflict of interest. Land use is often managed by a government agency such as the ministry of land. These agencies are led by commissioners who make decisions on how public land should be used. In this context, commissioners can make land use decisions that serve their interests at the expense of the public.

Examples of conflict of interest in land management initiatives include the following. To begin with, commissioners can enjoy personal financial benefits by voting for decisions that affect a region where they own large pieces of land (Sanghera and Satybaldieva 96-114).

Remember! This is just a sample
You can get your custom paper by one of our expert writers

For example, a commissioner can vote against controlled development in a municipality where he owns land so that he can construct as many buildings as possible. Conflict of interest can also occur if the decision taken by a commissioner can benefit any of his blood relatives. The benefit can be in the form of financial gain or unfair acquisition of land.

Finally, conflict of interest can occur if land use issues are used by politicians as a complain agenda in order to attract voters. In this case, politicians make land use promises which might be popular but not beneficial to the public. According to the principle of common good, any act that leads to conflict of interest in land use or management is wrong.

A common good is achieved when land management decisions enhance social welfare in the community (MacKinnon 89). It is also achieved when land management decisions promote peace and security. In the contrary, conflict of interest often leads to tensions and confrontations. For instance, biased land use policies led to bloody confrontations between Africans and whites in South Africa during the apartheid period.

The principles of land ethic should be upheld in situations where conflicts of interest are likely to arise. In this regard, the behavior of a decision-maker is deemed to be right if he abstains from taking any decision or action regarding land use that directly benefits him or his close relatives at the expense of the society. For instance, a land commissioner should disqualify himself from voting in a decision-making process that affects a region where he owns a relatively large piece of land.

Finally, ethical obligations should be applicable in the local and the adjacent jurisdiction (MacKinnon 112). It is apparent that communities do not exist in isolation. Thus, their land use behaviors are likely to affect neighboring communities. For instance, farming along the upstream banks of a river will lead to water pollution which eventually affects the downstream communities. This is likely to happen if the river is an open access water resource (Sanghera and Satybaldieva 96-114).

Even though the upstream communities have a right to use the river’s water for farming, their action is wrong since it hurts the downstream communities. If the upstream and downstream communities belong to different jurisdictions, the right action will involve enforcing land use policies that are binding in both jurisdictions. Concisely, each community must take responsibility for its behavior by refraining from any action that pollutes the river.

Conclusion

Ethics refers to principles and guidelines that govern the behavior of individuals in the society (Brassard 497-500). In the context of land use and management, these principles help individuals and communities to distinguish between right and wrong behaviors. However, community members often disagree on what should be classified as right or wrong land use behavior due to underlying values and attitudes.

Thus, certain behaviors can be deemed to be right and acceptable by some individuals. However, the same behaviors can be considered to be immoral, inappropriate and unacceptable by others. Consequently, the community must agree on common ethical standards that will guide the behavior of its members in regard to land use. This leads to the conclusion that an ethical individual must do what is right to do, rather than what he has a right to do.

We will write
a custom essay
specifically for you
Get your first paper with
15% OFF

Works Cited

Brassard, Paul. “Social and Land Use Ethics Surrounding Land Trusts.” Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economcis 42.2 (2000): 497-500. Print.

MacKinnon, Barbara. Ethics: Theory and Contemporary Issues. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2010. Print.

Sanghera, Balihar and Elmira Satybaldieva. “Ethics of Property, Illegal Settlements and the Right to Subsistence.” International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 32. 1 (2012): 96-114. Print.

Wotapka, Dawn. “College Housing Firms Aim Upscale.” Wall Street Journal. Dow Jones and Company. 23 Oct. 2012. Web.

Print
Need an custom research paper on Ethics and Land Use Behavior written from scratch by a professional specifically for you?
808 writers online
Cite This paper
Select a referencing style:

Reference

IvyPanda. (2019, November 20). Ethics and Land Use Behavior. https://ivypanda.com/essays/ethics-and-land-use-behavior/

Work Cited

"Ethics and Land Use Behavior." IvyPanda, 20 Nov. 2019, ivypanda.com/essays/ethics-and-land-use-behavior/.

References

IvyPanda. (2019) 'Ethics and Land Use Behavior'. 20 November.

References

IvyPanda. 2019. "Ethics and Land Use Behavior." November 20, 2019. https://ivypanda.com/essays/ethics-and-land-use-behavior/.

1. IvyPanda. "Ethics and Land Use Behavior." November 20, 2019. https://ivypanda.com/essays/ethics-and-land-use-behavior/.


Bibliography


IvyPanda. "Ethics and Land Use Behavior." November 20, 2019. https://ivypanda.com/essays/ethics-and-land-use-behavior/.

Powered by CiteTotal, the best referencing machine
If you are the copyright owner of this paper and no longer wish to have your work published on IvyPanda. Request the removal
More related papers
Cite
Print
1 / 1