Introduction
In her essay An Intersection of Biography and History, Mary Romero examines the lives of Latina domestic workers in the Los Angeles area. The author argues that the treatment she has experienced of domestic workers demonstrates the collective experience of inequality and oppression that Latin Americans have faced. This essay aims to critically evaluate the information presented by Romero to understand the topic’s problems better.
Analysis
By describing her mother’s experience as a servant, the author demonstrates her deep understanding of the problem (Romero 20). Juanita’s story introduces the topic of domestic service work and the problems many domestic workers face. To do this, the author demonstrates an ambivalent attitude towards Juanita, whose employer allegedly seeks to help the girl, but simultaneously demonstrates a cruel attitude towards her (Romero 21). Romero finds this problematic, as it heavily reminds her of her experience as a house cleaner during her teen years.
Their unique experience justifies the choice of the group of workers. The Chicanas’ experience has been shaped not only by their ethnicity but also by their gender identity, socioeconomic situation, and level of education (Romero 21). Romero adds to the study the historical context of the Mexican-American War, immigration, and US domestic service history (Romero 27).
Most of the workers in Romero’s study were ashamed to call their previous occupation as a house cleaner a fully worthy job. Many women in Romero’s academic department felt uncomfortable about her research, as some were employers of such domestic cleaners. They found no offense in their actions and attitude toward their workers. They discussed the possibility of their work as cashiers and deliveries.
Our ideas about home being a “private sphere” are challenged when opposed to those doing domestic work for a living. According to Romero, when housework is paid, there are clear agreements on roles and compensations (29). Since many people tend not to consider it a serious business, persuading them to think differently is difficult. No matter what social group is selected, any labor should be paid for, especially when it involves much physical activity.
Conclusion
In conclusion, stories from personal experience and other women’s experiences, which the author uses, allow for a better understanding of the problem of domestic workers. This study forces a critical assessment of the conditions in which Latin women worked. In addition, the historical perspective helps to understand the causes of long-term social injustice in America.
Work Cited
Romero, Mary. Maid in the USA. Routledge, 2016.
Loading...
