A Summary of Rand’s Major Points in The Virtue of Selfishness
In her work The Virtue of Selfishness, Ayn Rand posits that ethics embodies a system of values that serves as a compass to steer man’s choices and deeds, thereby shaping the meaning and trajectory of his existence. She contends that the initial question that necessitates an answer in the definition of ethics is why man requires a code of values. Rand asserts that the need for values arises from the indeterminate nature of man’s life, wherein his prosperity depends on his actions and objectives. She claims that ethics is grounded upon rationality and constitutes an indispensable facet of human beings.
One example of Rand’s argument is her assertion that man’s life is the standard of value in ethics. She states, “The standard of value of the Objectivist ethics—the standard by which one judges what is good or evil—is man’s life, or that which is required for man’s survival qua man.” Rand explains that man’s life is the standard because it is the ultimate goal that all other values serve.
A Fallacy That Rand Makes in Her Theory
The flaw in Rand’s assertion resides in her assumption that all individuals possess a uniform understanding of what is necessary for their survival and the significance of values. She posits reason as the solitary means for survival, claiming that all individuals should prioritize it. Nonetheless, this neglects the fact that individuals differ in their needs, capacities, and circumstances, thus necessitating distinct values and courses of action for their survival.
The black-or-white fallacy is a fallacy that Rand makes in her theory. This fallacy happens when there are just two options available, ignoring the potential of a third or middle option. Rand argues that reason is the only way to survive and that everyone should put it first. This ignores the reality that people have different needs, abilities, and situations, which means that other values and strategies are needed for them to survive. Rand overlooks the variety and complexity of the human experience as well as the wide range of variables that might affect a person’s survival and well-being by promoting a single option as the best one.
Loading...
