Miranda’s Communication Style with Andy
In the movie “The Devil Wears Prada” (2006), communication styles between the characters of Miranda Priestly, played by Meryl Streep, and Andy Sachs, portrayed by Anne Hathaway, are strikingly different and noteworthy. Miranda Priestly, the editor-in-chief of a high-end fashion magazine, uses a communication style that is distinctively authoritative, assertive, and direct.
Miranda’s communication style is somewhat effective in her position of power, particularly in the cutthroat fashion industry. She communicates her expectations clearly, leaving no room for ambiguity. Her use of direct and assertive communication ensures that her employees know precisely what she wants when she wants it, and how she wants it done. For instance, when Andy walks into the office, Miranda swiftly lists off a series of tasks for her to accomplish without any hesitation, clearly demonstrating her direct approach.
However, the effectiveness of Miranda’s communication style is subjective and may be perceived as intimidating or overbearing by some. While it may foster efficiency and productivity, it can also lead to a stressful work environment, potentially causing employees to feel undervalued and disrespected. For example, Miranda routinely dismisses Andy’s input and often belittles her, which eventually leads to a strained relationship between the two characters.
Pros and Cons of Miranda’s Communication Style
There are both advantages and disadvantages to Miranda’s style of communication. On the one hand, it ensures efficiency, reduces confusion, and promotes a strict professional environment. On the other hand, it can create a hostile work environment, contribute to low morale, and limit open dialogue. Miranda’s communication style is often one-sided, which is evident when she interrupts or dismisses Andy without giving her an opportunity to voice her thoughts or concerns.
Andy’s Communication Style with Miranda
In the video, through the character of Andy Sachs, we can see a clear example of a passive and accommodating communication style. Andy is new to the fashion world and is constantly trying to adapt to Miranda’s high demands. She often responds to Miranda’s requests and orders in a soft, respectful, and submissive manner, even when she feels overwhelmed or mistreated.
This style is evident when Miranda, played by Meryl Streep, asks Andy to fetch the unpublished Harry Potter manuscript for her twins (JoBlo Movie Clips, 2021). Despite being an unreasonable demand, Andy nods and sets on to fulfill it without any argument.
Her patience and resilience also characterize Andy’s communication style. In many instances, she remains calm and composed, even when Miranda is being overly demanding or critical. For example, when Miranda criticizes Andy’s sense of fashion and her inability to understand the fashion industry, Andy doesn’t react defensively. Instead, she takes the criticism as constructive feedback and later improves her fashion sense, showing resilience.
Furthermore, Andy tends to avoid confrontations and prefers to resolve issues in a non-confrontational manner. When Miranda throws her coat and bag at Andy without any acknowledgment or appreciation, Andy doesn’t confront her about her disrespectful behavior. Instead, she silently picks them up and continues with her work, showcasing a high level of tolerance and adaptability.
In comparison, Miranda’s communication style is assertive, direct, and sometimes aggressive (JoBlo Movie Clips, 2021). She clearly communicates her expectations and doesn’t hesitate to express her dissatisfaction if they are not met. Her tone and body language often dominate the conversation, leaving little room for others to voice their opinions or concerns.
Personal Reflection on Communication Styles
I chose Andy’s style because it resonates with my personal belief in open dialogue, empathy, and understanding. Despite the challenges she faces, Andy remains committed to her role, showing adaptability and professionalism. Her passive communication style, however, does not mean she is weak or submissive. Instead, she displays emotional intelligence by attempting to balance the demands of her job with maintaining her integrity.
References
JoBlo Movie Clips. (2021). THE DEVIL WEARS PRADA Clip – “Personal Assistant” (2006)[Video]. YouTube. Web.
JoBlo Movie Clips. (2021). THE DEVIL WEARS PRADA Clip – “Andy Gets a Makeover” (2006) [Video]. YouTube. Web.
Loading...
