Introduction
A Brief Account of the Destruction of the Indies (Brief Account) is a report for the King of Spain that explores the acts of violence and gold accumulation of Spanish colonizers in the New World. Although the main aim of the expedition was to bring Christianity to the native inhabitants, the Spaniards chose to disregard the given instructions and brutally murdered countless indigenous people in order to confiscate their gold.
The Brief Account is mainly an argumentative text lacking a clear narrative; however, it does follow the chronological and geographical sequence of events during the Spanish conquest, with each chapter focusing on a specific region. De las Casas employs a straightforward emotional approach in depicting the surrounding events, aiming to invoke empathy and sympathy for the innocent and naive Indigenous people rather than over-relying on sophisticated or complex argumentation. However flawed it may be, the Brief Account has been instrumental in bringing to light the horrific deeds conducted by Spanish colonizers, providing a different opinion on colonization, and impacting contemporary research and thinking.
Atrocities Committed by Spanish Colonizers
The main subject discussed throughout the text is the Spanish’s inhumane attitude toward the indigenous community. De las Casas delineates the numerous ways in which the Spanish inflicted harm upon both the inhabitants and the environment of the islands throughout each chapter. Being the Dominican friar himself, de las Casas wrote the Brief Account from a Christian perspective (6). He frequently brought up the colonists’ actions as lacking religiousness and compared their greed to the worship of fake idols. In this context, the natives were perceived by de las Casas and the other friars as peaceful and docile (6; 29). They cordially welcomed any Spanish men who arrived in their territory (de las Casas 77).
Regrettably, their excessive kindness often led to their homes being invaded and themselves being abused by others. The Spanish knew of their welcoming customs and exploited the locals’ kind-heartedness, using it as an opportunity to pilfer from the towns and villages (de las Casas, 77). Due to the Spanish people’s actions, countless native individuals lost their lives, causing many others to endure extreme hardships, all for the sake of the desired gold, jewels, and slaves.
De Las Casas’ Perception of Colonization
While the majority of the Brief Account focuses on these inhuman acts, they do not form the central focus of de las Casas’s story. His ultimate desire is for the violence to stop, as his main goal is the proliferation of Christianity in the New World. The Spanish greed and violence effectively prevented the natives from learning knowledge about Christ.
The natives’ physical suffering on Earth deeply saddened and distressed de las Casas; however, he noted his utmost worry lying in their eternal anguish should they not adopt Christianity (46, 65, 74). This indicates the author’s belief in the Spaniards’ entitlement to own the New World. Nonetheless, this authority is bestowed upon the Spanish due to their Christian faith, which should compel them to employ their power in accordance with Christian principles. By cautioning against brutal misconduct, he emphasizes that it does not only harm the natives and lead to dire consequences in the afterlife for the conquerors but also puts Spain at risk of invoking God’s wrath (de las Casas 10). He implores the Spanish Crown to take action and halt the violence before it reaches a critical point.
Book’s Credibility and Impact
De las Casas’ work can be considered both unique and traditional at the same time. He boldly expressed disapproval towards his nation’s policies while giving recognition to the accomplishments and cultural contributions of Native Americans, which was not common contemporary behavior. Moreover, his audacity in voicing his concerns to the King and ultimately publishing his book is truly commendable (de las Casas 9).
Furthermore, considering the King’s empathetic response to his complaints, it is reasonable to assume that the majority of his statements had a significant moral influence on the Spanish nobility. Specifically, de las Casas gave voice to concerns regarding the justification of Spanish colonial policy, which the country had had for a considerably long time but opted to delay. His thinking approach and thoughtful and targeted argumentation can be considered precedents for the mindset and manner that would become prevalent among 20th-century scholars. De las Casas adhered to an intellectual lineage that was established by renowned thinkers such as Aristotle and St. Thomas Aquinas (de las Casas 16). His genuine dedication to his role left a profound impact on a significant number of aspiring religious leaders and scholars.
Conclusion
Overall, the Brief Account has been instrumental in revealing the horrific deeds perpetrated by Spanish colonizers, disseminating an alternative outlook on colonization, and influencing scholarly and political thought. In terms of the former, a detailed illustration of Spaniards’ general brutality, violence toward the indigenous people, and lust for personal gain effectively shocks the readers, managing to invoke empathy and compassion. De las Casas was not afraid of providing a unique perspective on how colonization should be conducted, not critiquing the Spanish for their authoritative claims but for their immoral attitudes from a Christian perspective. As a result, his work had a profound impact on the minds of Spanish mobility, the public, and the scholarly field due to the combination of factors mentioned above.
In terms of its strengths and weaknesses, the book displays a profound emotional appeal but is lacking in scientific and logical argumentation. That is, the author’s main motivator is faith; adherence to Christian ideals and belief in God’s will form the bulk of his argument, which has little scientific worth. In this context, greater religious objectivity supported by thorough statistical evidence could have enhanced the book’s impact.
Work Cited
de las Casas, Bartolomé. The Devastation of the Indies: A Brief Account. JHU Press, 1992.
Loading...
