Introduction
There are many cultures and minorities in the world, each with unique traditions, customs, and values. However, sometimes people advocate for the rights of minorities and other cultures. Therefore, in such cases, it is crucial to follow ethical principles to respect cultural sensitivity and avoid causing harm to the people they represent. Thus, the book Intercultural Communication raises an essential dilemma about whether it is worth speaking on behalf of others.
In the book, the author addresses the issues of cultural representation. Cultural representation can be used to manipulate and control the masses. Some groups may use cultural representation to establish their power and suppress other cultural groups. Such factors can lead to conflicts and distrust between different cultural groups (Halualani, 2022). The key dilemma that Halualani highlights is whether it is better to speak for other cultures and face the consequences or to remain silent and do nothing.
Addressing Other Cultural Groups’ Challenges
In this way, we should speak for others when other cultural groups need advocacy and alliances, and non-movement action might be dangerous. If people remain silent for others, it might show disrespect and promote tension between interlocutors. Speaking for other cultures can be helpful if it is done with respect for the culture and with the consent of its representatives.
For example, suppose a speech is aimed at supporting a minority group that is experiencing discrimination, and representatives of this group request assistance. In that case, you can speak on their behalf, provided you have conducted a thorough study of their culture (Halualani, 2022). It was reportedly not coordinated with representatives of the culture and did not take into account their opinions and experiences. In that case, this can lead to negative consequences, thereby strengthening stereotypes and prejudices.
It is essential to remember that every culture has its unique history, traditions, and experiences, and one must respect and understand these aspects to effectively speak on their behalf. The traditions and culture of each subsequent generation, along with the preservation of the primary experience inherited from their ancestors, acquire their ways of self-expression (Halualani, 2022). Thus, it is essential to exercise caution and respect when speaking on behalf of other cultures, and to always consider their perspectives and experiences.
Danger of “Non-Movement/Non-Action” on Behalf of Others
An example of dubious outside influence on the culture of the people is the Black Lives Matter movement and its subsequent development. Initially, the message was positive, but then the movement turned into looting. People should advocate for other cultures if the people and their problems really need to be publicized.
Therefore, it depends on the situation and context (Halualani, 2022). At the same time, each culture is an integrity with its own mental core, which sets the boundaries of cultural interpenetration. It is essential to consider cultural peculiarities and differences, treat them respectfully, and recognize the right to uniqueness. Sometimes, outside involvement can cause an undesirable reaction.
Conclusion
In the book Intercultural Communication, the author touches on an essential topic of cultural representation. A significant dilemma is raised, whether it is right to advocate for other cultures or to keep silent about the problems and stay away. In conclusion, when advocating for the rights and interests of other cultures and minorities, it is essential to observe ethical principles that respect cultural sensitivity and avoid harming those with whom you interact. Respect for cultural differences, a study and understanding of culture and minorities, the use of correct language and terminology, and respect for personal boundaries and the rights of these groups’ representatives will help us speak for others more effectively and respectfully.
Reference
Halualani, R. T. (2022). How do I represent culture? In Intercultural communication : A critical perspective. Cognella.