Introduction
The adverse impact of reality TV on the young generations is immense yet poorly explored, as this type of media rarely has any consistency behind its content. The article “Reality TV: A ghastly plague upon modern society” by John Mclennan explores this subject to comprehend the reasons behind its existence.
Author Credibility and Professional Background
Although the author was a student when writing the article, he provides an in-depth analysis of this media phenomenon, sending a clear warning to readers who may still be consuming such a product. The writer’s use of pathos in his paper creates a convincing, persuasive argument against reality TV.
Content Analysis: Messages, Omissions, and Argument Balance
This writing compels readers to stop watching empty shows with questionable morals. McLennan (2013) states that “an unhealthy dose of bad morals” is all this type of media offers (para. 2). In fact, the author highlights that reality TV has no substance. It is reasonable to state that the article presents only a single side of the argument. McLennan reviews are based on their popularity rather than the variety of content from many sources, which may include insightful topics.
Timeliness and Historical Context
Although the article was written ten years ago, it has not lost its point, as reality TV continues to plague modern media channels. The realism part of such shows requires viewers to put a high degree of belief in their producers, as many shows exhibit signs of scripted scenes taking place for dramatic effect (McLennan, 2013). Indeed, this notion did not change over the years, as such entertainment relies on drama at its core.
Source Type and Quality
While researchers make claims included in the paper, no direct links to the studies confirm the author’s conclusions, making the entire writing appear less credible. However, this part does not diminish McLennan’s arguments, yet adds ethos to his point. The article seems to stem from popular press material since it relies on its emotional charge rather than scientific findings.
Rhetorical Approach: Pathos, Style, and Examples
The primary goal of the story appears to be the persuasion of its readers, as the author attempts to dissuade people from watching this type of media. The writer provides arguments in favor of his opinion, which reveals the emptiness of reality TV shows in terms of thought-provoking content by highlighting their absurdity (McLennan, 2013). As seen in Table 1, the author’s heavy use of rhetorical tools influences the audience’s views on this kind of media. The only positive side of reality TV shows, arguably beneficial to society, is the opportunity to socialize, which is provided by discussions around this content (McLennan, 2013). The article lacks logos while relying on the other two convincing types.
To achieve his goals, the writer uses metaphors and similes, hyperbolizing the impact of reality TV and accumulating related examples of poor-quality shows. The rhetorical question this article poses ushers readers to explore the core of reality TV for its fictional aspects (McLennan, 2013). Through these tools, McLennan provokes his audience to reconsider their position on the subject and stand against this mass media phenomenon.
Moreover, the choice of examples for the paper confirms that the persuasive aspect relies heavily on creating a negative image of reality TV. For example, by revealing how some shows focus on belittling their participants, the author appeals to one’s sense of justice (McLennan, 2013). The stylistic elements of pathos are apparent and highly convincing, as they appear logically sound and emotionally provoking.
Table 1. Stylistic Devices in the Article
Conclusion
In conclusion, the author delivers a set of persuasive arguments against reality TV by evoking negative emotions in the audience through stylistic devices that highlight the downsides of such entertainment. Indeed, there are adverse effects stemming from exposure to these shows, as their moral value is lacking. The author uses stylistic elements that emphasize the negativity around this content, such as drama and shock value. Even though the paper was written in 2013 by a student, it holds true today. It appears that reality TV is barely discernible, as McLennon claims.
Reference
Mclennan, J. (2013). Reality TV: A ghastly plague upon modern society. Opinion Panel.