“The Favorite Child” by Ellen Weber Libby Essay

The work by Ellen Weber Libby titled “The Favorite Child” contains three types of claims: claims of fact, claims of value, and claims of policy. Claims of facts show that the non-acceptance of the separation of children into favored and unfavored carries negative outcomes for both them and their parents (Libby, 2010). Moreover, it can be attributed to this kind of argument that this distinction can lead to psychological problems in minors. Claims of value may be an indication that not confirming the presence of a beloved child is not a taboo topic in society. In addition, being an unfavored child can negatively affect an individual’s future social interactions and the formation of self-identity and self-worth (Libby, 2010). Regarding policy statements, reading provides information that communication in the family is important to solve potential problems associated with becoming a favored or unfavored child.

The reading “The favorite child” raised three questions that will help critically analyze the assumptions, evidence, and credibility of the source.

1. The author pointed out that studies show that the division of children into favored and unfavored negatively affects the psychological state and cause depression and latent aggression. Is there recent evidence that an open conversation about this phenomenon cannot cause this kind of deviation? This is due to the fact that when disclosing this information, pressure can have a detrimental impact on the individual.
2. Reading argues that individuals need parental affirmation, but its excess can negatively affect their independence. In what ways can parents achieve this aspect without going to the extremes of excessive limitation or overloading children with their love?
3. Regarding credibility, the author mentions studies that may support claims about the development of depression n both the favored and unfavored child. Are there studies that emphasize the validity of other arguments highlighted by the author?

Reference

Libby, E. W. (2010). The favorite child: How a favorite impacts every family member for life. Prometheus Books.