Introduction
In a Facebook advertisement for Dove cosmetics, a black lady unbuttoned her dark top to reveal a white woman sporting a bright blouse below. Most people who complained about the Unilevel-owned company’s soap advertisements said that the advert showed and implied discrimination. This commercial triggered an ongoing discussion regarding the pervasive racial stereotypes seen in soap opera ads (An 12). After taking off her dark clothing, which some people claimed was racist and inaccurately represented black people, the black woman is cleansed into whiteness. The advertisement for the soap made by the Unilevel-owned firm implied to its target market that the black woman was filthy before using the product but had become clean and white as a result. The light shirt depicted the white woman as clean, whereas the voila-colored garment showed the black woman as unclean. In this essay, the development of a semiotic analysis will be the main focus to create a more comprehensive comprehension of the racial advertisement created by the Dove Company.
Semiotic Analysis
The study of social, cultural, and natural notions is done through semiotic analysis. The world is made up of various signals having both literal and figurative value. The use of the sign system and how meaning is created in social production are discussed. For example, ads are a type of visual art where each picture representation can partially serve as a sign (Rose 305). The semiotic analysis is crucial because it aims to explain the significance of signs utilized in a certain way. For example, photography is the genre since the racist Dove advertisement uses a picture inside an image. The ad’s graphic showed occasions when the white lady who appears later had smooth skin while the black woman in the picture had broken skin.
According to the advertisement, the white woman is superior to the black woman and has more attractive skin. The woman’s blackness was a sign of her filthy skin and dirt since, after a few seconds, she had whiter skin and had been cleaned. The prejudiced advertisement portrays black people as unattractive and as having undesirable attributes. In contrast, white people are denoted by lighter complexion, symbolizing their higher level of beauty. Furthermore, the advertisement implies that white people enjoy more significant benefits than black people, who lack specific attributes and privileges due to where they live.
Racism Theoretical Notion
The racist advertisement created and developed may be examined through the prism of core theoretical notions as a significant participant in the corporate sector and an affiliate company of a major multinational corporation. One of the conceptual frameworks that might be applied to this investigation is racism. Stereotypes can influence how people are seen when both sides are anonymous (Rose 275). Race is a created social category used to classify individuals and give social context to their behavior. Racism is the deliberate and systematic transfer of resources, privileges, and power from all other races to the dominant race via the establishment of social, political, economic, and cultural institutions, practices, and beliefs. Racism, which is a sort of prejudice towards social groupings, consists of three connected but distinct elements: discrimination (behavioral bias), prejudice (emotional bias), and stereotypes (cognitive bias). youth who identify as non-dominant racial or ethnic (NDRE) and those who work with young people can both suffer harmful impacts from racism.
Gender and racial diversity in advertising imagery across businesses are essential since these pictures are tailored to meet the models and representations of the target market and social media viewers. As it results in incomplete citizenship, discounted rights, undervalued respect, and undervalued participation, racism fosters power imbalances that reduce social inclusion and boost an oppressive society. However, producers and marketers have a lot of opportunity and power to address this problem (Chandler). The nuanced picture in the Dove advertisement depicts various levels of racial intolerance. Researchers claim that blatant racism in advertising has been replaced with subtle imagery in ads. The promotion was a subtly racist depiction of black people. According to academics, covert racism in advertising has replaced overt racism (Berger 63). Advertising with overt racial imagery has clear stereotyped connotations; advertising with subtle racial imagery is less clear. Subtle Racist Imagery in Ads should alter due to this overt-to-subtle transition into negative stereotyping, which frequently involves Blacks.
In essence, this is why the advertisement presented black people as less fortunate and unsuitable while portraying white people as perfect. By integrating positive pictures and advertisements about black women, we may reject stereotypes and increase the representation of black women in society. They and their well-being stand to gain a great deal from this. Additionally, the advertisement shows negative stereotyping of black women, frequently perceived as racism and prejudice. Furthermore, it is viewed unfavorably as a show of inferiority when black women are prominently featured in a poor position in advertising.
For instance, the black lady in the racist Dove advertisement is shown to be inadequate and still lacking in critical characteristics. This image frequently denigrates women, forcing them to seek out manipulative screen presence through objectification to improve their appearance and feel valued by society (Gershon). In other cases, women stop participating in activities that need them and stop exposing themselves as much. For instance, many black women felt terrified by being shown as filthy things in this Dove racist issue. To avoid being seen, they could become more reclusive around cameras and become more active. Furthermore, it could inspire some people to get plastic surgery to objectify their bodies.
Influence of Ads on Subtle Racial Bias
This semiotic study’s primary objective is to pinpoint the impact of subtle racial prejudice in advertising. Priming elements in advertisements can occasionally lead to biasness, even while corporations successfully hide the core ideas of racial biasness (Garcia). The racist Dove campaign is a prime example, in which the company denied having any racial motivations while making it quite evident in their advertisement that they were racially discriminatory. Therefore, the impact of eliminating masking attractiveness and favorably depicting black women may be assessed to evaluate racial imagery. Experiences impact inherent bias, which can alter perceptions, conduct, and judgment (Wilson 8). Organizations must thoroughly examine the substance of their underlying material methodically using a deconstruction tool (Holes). The defining characteristic that separates white women from black women significantly impacts how race is defined today as the nation becomes more industrialized. Racist preconceptions often lead to condemnation of a black lady who appears in an advertisement. For example, a sizeable portion of the public criticized the black woman in the most recent Dove racial advertisement for agreeing to appear in the advertising. The lady in the ad defended herself, stating that she had no idea the commercial would be racially offensive.
The Dove advertisement was a textbook example of ethnic stereotyping and prejudice towards black women. The above confirms that the neutral factor that tries to cover up a negative stereotype is the critical component that best exemplifies a covert racial bias. Model roles and product categories are influenced by racial prejudice. For instance, Black models are overrepresented in sports/athletic goods commercials since they are commonly shown in those settings. The racist Dove advertisement uses comedy to normalize the stereotype of the black lady, giving the impression that the image is pleasant. However, in actuality, the main aim of such pictures is to spread prejudice and unfavorable stereotypes about black people. Subtle racist iconography has profoundly harmed and mistreated people of color.
These advertisements show one race as unclean and the other as clean. A historical story that has previously appeared in soap opera advertisements. With white and black characters, black people are often portrayed as poor, relying on historical instances where enslaved people were denied the same rights as white people due to their race and social standing. A story that may be said to be still present in the subliminal messages of Dove’s most recent advertisement (Chandler). To further feed the argument, Dove faced criticism in 2011 for implications in a commercial that seemed to depict women becoming cleaner as their skin tone lightened.
Dimensional Qualitative Research
Dimensional qualitative research (DQR) technology is desperately needed to uncover the underlying negative stereotype in racially biased advertisements and to determine the modalities that contribute most to a partial picture. DQR-based content evaluations look at the psychological aspects of advertising that are both intrinsic and extrinsic from a combination of teleological and deontological views (Helle). Through carefully crafted narratives or ad profiles that incorporate presumptions about latent phenomena, such studies can pinpoint traditionally determined manifest factors. Since they provide coder judgment impartiality, DQR-based content analyses are the most effective for identifying advertisement appeals that conceal negative visuals. DQR-based content studies are the best method for analyzing subtle negative stereotypes in advertisements for advertising experts, consumer organizations, corporate ethicists, and regulatory authorities.
Through the systematic use of a cognitive behavioral method, dimensional qualitative research seeks to improve the quality of qualitative consumer research. There is undoubtedly much to be said about the necessity for advertisers to go past the obvious and take the potential effects of their imagery into account, particularly concerning underrepresented groups of women. Customer satisfaction is vital as it enables marketers to foresee how consumers perceive their products (Harmon, Story Structure 101). One of the critical components of integrating immigrants and members of ethnic minorities is the perception of the other. Depending on how individuals regard themselves and other groups, integrating and working together in a multicultural society can be challenging or straightforward.
Mass media is a central avenue that influences how people see one another. After repeated exposure, the media’s mediated images cause viewers to change their views and attitudes. Therefore, how different demographic groups are depicted in media, especially ads, may significantly impact how those groups create their identities (Harmon, Story Structure 106). While exposure in advertisements still matters, more pertinent research would focus on how black people are depicted in these commercials. According to a study, black people’s early look is frequently disparaging. Black people are not viewed as having sufficient privilege or as being on par with white people. Although there is little indication of diversity in the commercial, the company argues that variety was supposed to be portrayed in the advertisement. The only representation of black people in the ad is as “filthy” white people.
More than that depicted in the commercial would be included in diversity. Diversity would significantly improve how the black group is viewed. The dominance of whites over blacks in the racist Dove advertisement is an example of stereotyped cultural imperialism. Advertisers could challenge this social image by portraying black people as culturally powerful and fully aware of their identity. Most black people are underrepresented, and when they appear, they tend to be men who work in service-related fields rather than managerial or professional positions. They should thus be given authority and demonstrated as crucial in visual ads (Harmon, Story Structure 103). The Dove racist commercial exemplifies the racial imbalance in magazine ads for outdoor recreational activities. Additionally, before publishing, advertising photos should be given serious study.
Advertisers must consider how consumers will react to the image of a man removing a black shirt to expose a white lady in a lighter shirt. It shows a prejudiced and racially stereotypical culture. Despite reimagining conventional black female characters in advertisements, there is still a significant problem with the depiction of black people and negative stereotyping. For many years, academics have examined how different ethnic minorities are portrayed in print and broadcast media ads compared to Whites. Minority groups have often been shown to be under or incorrectly represented in ads. For instance, commercials continue to promote stereotypical representations of races and gender, such as how women are shown as youthful, skinny, and happy and how African Americans are portrayed as aggressive and energetic. These research cautions have not stopped the creation of aggressive advertising like the one by Hornbach (Garcia). Therefore, it is crucial to analyze marketing and increase public awareness continuously.
Since most ads include visible elements owing to their effectiveness as marketing tools, assessing the visual content is one of the crucial aspects of advertising monitoring. Previous research examining advertising depended most on human labor to explore visual data. Monitoring the large volume of adverts in the modern world, swamped with digital information disseminated on social media and the web, requires minimizing such human efforts and developing an automated solution. The concepts of social justice leadership, which comprise active listening and establishing safe places for important talks about racism and race, should be adopted by organizations. Collective participatory methods are essential because they significantly reduce racial bias in advertisements and, as a result, reduce the possibility of racial imagery in ads (Helle). Minorities’ cognitive abilities are harmed considerably by racial marketing; thus, it is essential to consider their requirements while formulating ways to reduce bias.
Conclusion
In conclusion, it is evident from the discussion above that gender and racial diversity in media-mediated pictures affect how we see certain demographic groups. Through collaborative, system-wide methods informed by effective practices, there is a critical need to create, implement, and evaluate treatments, policies, and procedures. Advertising should emphasize fostering variety in society and a good view of minorities. Racial advertisements are harmful to people’s wellness. Diversity should be considered and promoted even more by encouraging high-quality representation and ought to represent the opinions of the audience. Dove fell short in this case because it did not engage with its customers sufficiently to understand that diversity is only superficial if the stereotype of white people as neutral is upheld.
Works Cited
An Jisun. Gender and Racial Diversity in Commercial Brands’ Advertising Images on Social Media [online]2019, p. 15, Web.
Berger, Arthur Asa. “Trump: A Semiotic Analysis.” Chinese Semiotic Studies, vol. 15, no. 1, 2019, pp. 49–75, Web.
Chandler, Daniel. “Semiotics for Beginners.” Semiotics for Beginners: DIY Semiotic Analysis, 2020, Web.
Garcia, Kevin. “The Monomyth: You’re Doing It Wrong.” Monomythic, 2018, Web.
Gershon, Livia. “The Racism of 19th-Century Advertisements | JSTOR Daily.” JSTOR Daily, 2019, Web.
Harmon, Dan. “Story Structure 101: Super Basic Shit.” Channel 101 Wiki, Web.
Harmon, Dan. “Story Structure 103: Let’s Simplify before Moving On.” Channel 101 Wiki, Web.
Harmon, Dan. “Story Structure 106: Five Minute Pilots.” Channel 101 Wiki, Web.
Helle, Sophus. “How Disney Took to Subverting Its Romantic Ideals: Aeon Essays.” Aeon, Aeon Magazine, Web.
Holes, Square. “What Is Semiotic Analysis?” Square Holes – an Awe Inspiring Future Will Come from Deeply Understanding Real People, Web.
Rose, Gillian. Visual Methodologies: An Introduction to Researching with Visual Materials. 2001. 4th edition, Sage, 2016, p. 473.
Wilson, Stephen A. “Racism Is Real. Racism Is Complicated. Racism Is Real Complicated.” Family Medicine, vol. 51, no. 1, 2019, pp. 8–10, Web.