Introduction
The incorporation of ethical standards into Telehealth practice is critical because, in recent years, the utilization of information and communication technology (ICT) to offer health services has expanded significantly. There is a need to reduce healthcare costs and improve the efficiency with which services are delivered. The application of Telehealth techniques is essential to achieving the aforementioned objective. Recent health challenges have prompted health practitioners to adopt internet-based strategies to facilitate service delivery. The aforementioned modalities present challenges, including ensuring data safety.
Preserving patient confidentiality is critical, and various measures have been implemented to ensure it. Ethical dilemmas that require applying the principles of autonomy and nonmaleficence, along with personal and social values, arise when telemedicine is used to address health conditions. The ethical dilemma arises when a health practitioner must deliver telemedicine services in a setting where patient confidentiality cannot be guaranteed. The highlighted scenario is important in nursing because delivering healthcare services to disadvantaged communities is essential. Examining the ethical challenges of telemedicine in clinical practice prepares practitioners to address dilemmas effectively.
Ethical Dilemma: Telehealth and Patient Confidentiality
The maintenance of confidentiality in telemedicine is dependent on the ability to control the environment in which consultations occur. It is particularly challenging to offer telemedicine services in resource-poor settings where patients are gathered in a single location and privacy is not guaranteed. In some instances, confidential information regarding an individual’s health may be exposed to unintended parties.
In addition, the security of such information is at risk if a large number of patients use one device to access healthcare personnel. Unauthorized individuals may access files and documents with information on other people’s private data. The dilemma arises when a practitioner is required to provide services in environments where establishing confidentiality is arduous. Lee et al. (2021) note that COVID-19 brought unprecedented challenges to the delivery of healthcare services. Marginalized communities face difficulties accessing essential services due to the scarcity of resources and Telehealth options.
Moral Issues Raised by the Situation
Telehealth and patient confidentiality raise specific moral concerns that warrant examination. There has been a significant increase in the use of Telehealth services after the COVID-19 pandemic, as demonstrated by the policy changes in Table 1 below. Healthcare practitioners are increasingly aware of the barriers to Telehealth, such as the need for physical examinations, the lack of reimbursement parity, and disparities in state licensing and laws (Houser et al., 2023).
Vulnerable groups face greater challenges than others when using healthcare technology, raising privacy and security concerns (Houser et al., 2023). There are specific cultural factors that affect the application of Telehealth services across contexts (Baumes et al., 2020). Some communities have difficulty accepting the fact that telemedicine consultations are confidential. Although there have been substantial temporary improvements in Telehealth regulations at the federal and state levels, long-term changes to support Telehealth services have taken longer to implement, despite the ongoing demand.
Table 1 – Policy Changes Before and After the Pandemic
(Source: Shaver, 2022)
Bioethical Principles
The key bioethical principles involved in the decision regarding Telehealth and confidentiality are autonomy and nonmaleficence. The principle of autonomy refers to the process through which a nurse respects a patient’s right to choose a course of action and supports their independence when making decisions (Haahr et al., 2020). It is often challenging to see a patient make a health decision with which the nurse disagrees or believes is not the best, given the circumstances. For instance, a patient’s decision to decline to share Telehealth data with an expert ought to be respected. Nurses are expected to support and advocate for patient rights, especially when making decisions.
Recommendations for preserving or strengthening autonomy in Telehealth practice acknowledge that the ideas of choice and independence are not straightforward, especially for older or more vulnerable patients. The concept is often contextualized as the patient’s capacity to provide informed consent or actively participate in decision-making.
Keenan et al. (2021) contend that an ethical assessment design comprising five questions on patient autonomy should be implemented. The elements include co-design, behavioral modifications, comprehension of the system and its use under various scenarios, whether it improves independence, and if so, whether that independence is desirable (Keenan et al., 2021). Although a loss of autonomy may be inevitable for some Telehealth patients, particularly elderly users who are more receptive to traditional health care models, it should be minimized if possible.
Nonmaleficence is an essential bioethical principle in the provision of Telehealth services. It is based on the premise that healthcare practitioners must not intentionally cause harm(Della, 2023). While some treatments that are given to patients may cause pain or injury, nonmaleficence refers to the moral justification for the harm caused (Della, 2023).
In some instances, patients endure pain and discomfort to protect themselves from greater harm (Gebre-Mariam & Teame, 2021). For instance, their information may be shared with a professional to gain insight into their condition. Such interventions are justifiable if they benefit the patient and are not intended to harm them. However, if an act, such as sharing patient information, causes harm and prolongs suffering, it is not justifiable.
Personal Morality
Morally courageous behavior is essential for providing quality care and promoting safety. According to Pajakoski et al. (2021), moral courage is an individual’s inner strength when addressing ethical issues in accordance with ethical principles and personal values and beliefs, even if it means risking unfavorable personal repercussions. My personal values include the willingness to take personal risks to protect patient rights and to be accountable for all actions taken in health contexts. This means that, in scenarios involving prioritizing Telehealth data safety, the patient’s preferences are prioritized. In addition, patients must be informed of all breaches of confidentiality.
Relationship with Society
Society emphasizes the need to preserve private data at all costs. The willingness to take personal risks to ensure the patient’s best interests are prioritized aligns with the aforementioned societal moral code. When patients’ rights, safety, or quality of treatment are jeopardized, it is a nurse’s obligation to speak up and act as their advocate (Pajakoski et al., 2021).
Furthermore, doing the right thing by the patient and practicing quality nursing care is critical. Doing the right thing entails performing one’s duties in the best possible way, seeking the most effective solution for the patient, and accepting personal risks to protect the patient’s interests (Pajakoski et al., 2021). Society supports such actions, especially when they promote the protection of an individual’s autonomy and personal data.
Conclusion
Telehealth has revolutionized the delivery of patient care across various settings. While the modality has reduced costs and increased access to services, establishing confidentiality presents some difficulties. Practitioners face ethical dilemmas related to confidentiality when providing services in resource-poor settings.
The aforementioned challenge can be addressed by considering the bioethical principles of autonomy and nonmaleficence. The patient’s right to make decisions regarding the use of their information ought to be respected, and Telehealth services must not cause undue harm to individuals who use them. Elaborate measures to protect patient information must be implemented whenever feasible to ensure confidentiality.
References
Baumes, A., Čolić, M., & Araiba, S. (2020). Comparison of Telehealth-related ethics and guidelines and a checklist for ethical decision-making in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 13(4), 736–747.
Della, C. Y. (2023). Epistemic injustice and nonmaleficence. Journal of Bioethical Inquiry, 20(3), 447–456.
Gebreheat, G., & Teame, H. (2021). Ethical challenges of nurses in COVID-19 pandemic: Integrative review. Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare, 14, 1029–1035.
Haahr, A., Norlyk, A., Martinsen, B., & Dreyer, P. (2020). Nurses experiences of ethical dilemmas: A review. Nursing Ethics, 27(1), 258–272.
Houser, S. H., Flite, C. A., & Foster, S. L. (2023). Privacy and security risk factors related to Telehealth services – A systematic review. Perspectives in Health Information Management, 20(1), 1–10.
Keenan, A. J., Cert, G., Tsourtos, G., & Tieman, J. (2021). The value of applying ethical principles in Telehealth practices: Systematic review. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 23(3).
Lee, D. W. H., Tong, K. W., & Lai, P. B. S. (2021). Telehealth practice in surgery: Ethical and medico-legal considerations. Surgical Practice, 25(1), 42–46.
Pajakoski, E., Rannikko, S., Leino-Kilpi, H., & Numminen, O. (2021). Moral courage in nursing – An integrative literature review. Nursing & Health Sciences, 23(3), 570–585.
Shaver, J. (2022). The state of Telehealth before and after the COVID-19 pandemic. Primary Care, 49(4), 517-530.