Introduction
When working with a client, the psychologist often focuses on the client’s childhood memories and their relationship with their parents. It is a frequent phenomenon that the obvious abuse of power, force, or advantage in relation to a child repeats the model present in the adult’s family. This paper is devoted to the analysis of the victim-abuser relationship, as well as how these labels affect psychological practice and the relationship of these roles in the treatment process. Thus, this essay aims to answer the question: How to work with adults who have experienced mental trauma in childhood and are now traumatizing their children in a similar pattern?
Attitude Towards Adult Patients with Childhood Trauma
Personal Experience
I noticed that often the roots of abuse go back to childhood. The abuser can repeat the experience that they were given in childhood. Most of the abusers I know have experienced deprivation of emotional support and physical or emotional violence in the family. Therefore, they have formed negative behaviors that these abusers transfer into relationships with their partners or even children.
The abuser’s unfortunate experience as a victim creates a cycle of violence passed down from generation to generation. A person who was abused in his youth takes on the role of an abuser, continuing the harmful pattern. Thus, I noticed the cyclicity in the abuser-victim relationship: those who acted as victims in childhood often become abusers growing up.
Evidence-Based Practice
Victim and abuser labels can be the result of various factors such as personal experience, cultural stereotypes, social norms, and expectations. One of the approaches that psychologists suggest to break the victim-abuser cycle is the non-labeling approach (Lowe & Willis, 2019). Experts say one of the easiest ways to start dealing with labels and get rid of them is to pay attention to your thoughts and words. For example, when a patient finds themselves thinking about someone using the label abuser or victim, they should stop and analyze their thoughts (Lowe & Willis, 2019). The patient should identify what secondary benefit they experience by prescribing a particular label to themselves or their loved ones.
The label of victim or abuser can be beneficial to those who are in a psychologically unhealthy relationship. Using this label, they permit themselves to continue acting according to the old, familiar pattern. They should ask themselves where they got this information from and how true it is (Lowe & Willis, 2019).
Sometimes it’s useful to talk to someone who doesn’t share your views to gain a different perspective (Graham et al., 2021). A patient should also keep a diary and write down their thoughts about labeling victims and abusers there (Graham et al., 2021). This will help identify what lies behind the labels and how they slow the process of problem awareness and treatment.
A secondary benefit is an unconscious benefit that a person receives while in the position of a victim. This can manifest as a sense of security, comfort, self-pity, and other emotions. For example, if a person is in a relationship with an abuser, then he may enjoy being controlled and made to feel helpless (Graham et al., 2021). In such cases, people often do not realize that they benefit from their position as a victim, and do not want to change the situation.
Being labeled a victim, a person is not ready to constructively solve their problems. They complain and are convinced that someone else is to blame for their troubles. That is, the person themselves does not decide anything under the label of a victim and acts as if nothing in their life depends on them. They position themselves as weak and absolutely helpless in the face of the difficulties that have fallen on them (Graham et al., 2021).
The victim needs a person who is ready to take responsibility for their life, solve their problems, and protect them from the abuser. Thus, the secondary benefits of the victim label include getting attention and care and avoiding mistakes by making the wrong choice (Lowe & Willis, 2019). The victim avoids difficult tasks, shifting them onto the rescuer.
The abuser label also has secondary benefits. In an effort to get away from his own problems, refusing to admit his shortcomings, the abuser switches to another person, their victim. A person under the label of an abuser controls, pressures, and criticizes the victim, dominating them and asserting themselves at their expense (Lowe & Willis, 2019). The secondary benefits of the abuser label are the awareness of one’s impeccability and competence. By devaluing and suppressing the victim, the abuser is asserting themselves (Lowe & Willis, 2019). Moreover, a person with the abuser label benefits in the form of power and control, which gives them a sense of security.
It is possible to trace an example of the benefits of labels for each of the parties, considering the domestic situation of a quarrel. For example, an abusive wife accuses her husband of earning little, often drinking, and spending a lot of time lying on the couch in front of the TV. At the same time, the victim’s husband resents his wife for her claims, saying he is not to blame for how difficult it is to find a good, well-paid job. At the same time, he uses the victim label, which allows him to continue to do nothing and not look for a new job.
The wife remembers aloud that before her marriage, she was courted by a very promising man who now holds a highly paid position. The wife acts as an abuser, whose label allows her to devalue her husband by an unpleasant comparison with her ex (Graham et al., 2021). She feels sorry for herself for choosing a lazy husband, but she could have lived a completely different life and changed her mind about mink coats, as her ex-boyfriend’s wife is doing now. The wife took on the role of a victim, feeling sorry for herself over her wrong choice. It is advantageous for her to hide behind the role of a victim, since in this way she removes responsibility for the choice and shifts it to a person with the label of an abuser.
At the same time, depending on the benefits, the abuser and the victim may change labels. For example, after hearing that his wife remembers the former boyfriend and compares him to him, the husband is offended by his wife. He gets emotional, shouts at his wife, and threatens to divorce, becoming an abuser. At this point, the victim label becomes more advantageous for the wife. That way, she can neither admit her guilt for upsetting or angering her husband nor accuse him of offending her.
Thus, the adoption of labels by each participant in the abuser-victim cycle slows the solution of a specific problem. Each character must make their own decision: why do they wear this label, and what benefits does it give them? They should also wonder how great the degree of suffering is in this relationship and how they can be together with this person without being labeled a victim or an abuser. It often happens that one of the two people in this triangle decides to remove the label, and the cycle breaks (Graham et al., 2021). After that, if both people go beyond this triangle, they can become happy.
The victim always has a secondary benefit: the victim suffers and does nothing. They live in a way that keeps them from taking responsibility. It is difficult for the victim to live independently, and they are always looking for a rescuer, because they do not want to leave the passive zone to which they are accustomed (Lowe & Willis, 2019).
The victim does not want to take responsibility for themselves and for their life. They do not believe that change is possible, nor that something better can happen in their lives. If a person removes the label of ‘victim’ and continues to act appropriately, the situation will improve (Lowe & Willis, 2019). If it does not take off, then everything will remain the same, and they will live in suffering and disappointment.
The abuser seeks power over the other for various reasons: exalting himself above the victim and attacking them. They often come into this role if they were bullied at school as a child, or they were subjected to some violence and strong pressure (Lowe & Willis, 2019). At the same time, it may not be literal violence. This may be moral violence, when the mother puts pressure on the child and does not allow them to do what the child wants (Lowe & Willis, 2019).
In this case, such a child may develop abusive behavior in adulthood. If a person removes the label of an abuser, they will have to do a lot of work on themselves(Graham et al., 2021). Often, the abuser has very low self-esteem, a state of worthlessness, and unrealization, which is why they act this way (Lowe & Willis, 2019). Under the label of an abuser, complexes are hidden that are easier to suppress by domineering behavior towards the victim than to work through.
Conclusion
Thus, abusive relationships are very strong, codependent relationships in which people can switch roles. Depending on the availability of secondary benefits, the victim may become an abuser and vice versa, which is also confirmed by my personal experience. According to the studied evidence-based practice, the best way to deal with abuse is a non-labeling approach.
If the patient is aware of the secondary benefits derived from the label, it is easier to break the cycle of abusive-sacrificial relationships. Thus, supporting adults who endured childhood trauma and may be passing it on to their children mainly involves moving beyond labels. Only by understanding the secondary benefit will it be possible to change the behavior pattern to a healthier one.
References
Graham, A. C., Knopp, A. F., & Beers, K. (2021). I’m just a person: Self-labeling following sexual assault. Journal of Forensic Nursing, 17(4), 202-209.
Lowe, G., & Willis, G. (2019). “Sex offender” versus “person”: The influence of labels on willingness to volunteer with people who have sexually abused. Sexual Abuse, 32(5), 115-124.