The article under consideration dwells upon the practice of citing sources by scholars. The author argues that citation practices have become somewhat marginalized as authors fail to provide proper references to the sources they use.
Mooney (2011) also concludes that citation practices should be modernized as this can help to “foster responsible scholarship” (p. 99). The author addresses a specific question providing plausible arguments and arranges the arguments in a clear and concise way, which makes the article a relevant academic source.
Notably, Mooney (2011) provides a specific question to be answered. The author claims that there is certain lack in the guidelines “for citation of numeric data files” (Mooney, 2011, p. 100). It is possible to note that the author addresses rather a narrow field which is one of the most important features of a successful research.
The author uses plausible evidence to support her argument. Admittedly, there are different types of citation style. Hunter (n.d.) states that “mechanics of citing … vary in each format” (p. 1). Mooney (2011) also admits that “some domain-specific style guides provide clear examples for dataset citations” (p. 101).
The author even provides a specific pattern which was revealed in some of these sources. However, it is clear that there is no coherent system which could enable researchers to have a complete understanding of patterns to cite datasets used.
Furthermore, the article in question is well-organized. The author provides subheadings (e.g. “Data sharing and citations” or “Data citation standards”) which help the reader to follow the article (Mooney, 2011, p. 100). Admittedly, the subheadings help the author to organize arguments and help the reader to focus on what is really important.
On balance, it is possible to state that the author addresses a specific problem which, to great extent, ensures the success of the study. The author also provides relevant arguments which are clearly presented. The points mentioned above make the article a relevant academic work that provides important insights into the issue.
Reference List
Hunter, J. (n.d.). The importance of citation. Web.
Mooney, H. (2011). Citing data sources in the social sciences: Do authors do it? Learned Publishing, 24(2), 99-108.