Introduction
The United Nations (UN) Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) comprise 17 interconnected goals designed to guide action and reflection on the grave challenges facing the natural world and humanity. The coursework focuses on a critical aspect of the transformation project: SDG 12- responsible consumption and production. The world is struggling with social disparities, pollution, and resource depletion, underscoring the significance of the goal (Popescu, 2022).
The paper will begin with an introduction to the SDGs, their relevance and significance, and the crucial role of sustainability accounting. In addition, the report will explore a critical evaluation of SDG 12, incorporating personal commentaries where necessary. The next part will evaluate the evidence for the goal in a Chinese context. Furthermore, opinions and recommendations will be offered based on the available evidence. An evaluation of SDG 12 shows the world is not close to achieving the goal due to global crises and inefficient implementation.
SDGs as a Whole
SDGs are crucial since they serve as a global blueprint for sustainability, prosperity, and peace. They illustrate the world’s shared commitment to addressing problems such as hunger, environmental degradation, and climate change by 2030. The SDGs are important because they unite nations, individuals, and organizations around a common goal (Crane et al., 2019, p. 15). With 169 targets within 17 goals, the SDGs comprehensively seek to address interconnected challenges, such as poverty, inequality, sanitation, justice, and peace (Kakar, Popovski, and Robinson, 2023, p. 10). Thus, the SDGs serve as a beacon for individuals, organizations, and countries to build a more inclusive and sustainable world collectively.
SDGs contribute to ethical and sustainability arguments by acknowledging the interconnectedness of modern global challenges. Sustainability involves multiple aspects, including ecological preservation, poverty eradication, social inclusivity, and equitable access to resources (Bebbington et al., 2023, p. 22). By emphasizing the integration of such factors, the SDGs demonstrate that achieving true sustainability requires addressing systemic, interrelated problems.
Ethical arguments, such as the principles of human rights, fairness, and justice, support the entire SDG framework. Goals such as ‘quality education’ and ‘zero hunger’ represent ethical imperatives to ensure that the basic needs of humans are met for everyone, regardless of socio-economic status or geographical location. Furthermore, SDG 5 fosters gender equality, thereby reducing gender disparities, which aligns with the fairness principle (Bernstein and Vos, 2021). SDGs offer a normative framework that fundamentally aligns ethical imperatives with global progress.
Accounting for the SDGs is necessary because the goals serve as a measurable, comprehensive guide to progress. All goals have specific indicators that allow quantifiable assessments of setbacks and growth (Bebbington, Unerman, and O’Dwyer, 2014). Tracking progress is critical for accountability and transparency, ensuring commitments are converted into tangible activities. The integrative nature of SDGs necessitates collaboration across borders and sectors, making accounting valuable.
Additionally, SDG accounting enables informed decision-making, policy adjustments, and resource allocation (Laine, Tregidga, and Unerman, 2021, p. 82). It allows stakeholders, organizations, and governments to pinpoint success areas, areas for improvement, and challenges. The metrics linked to SDG accounting provide a common framework for entities to share their challenges and contributions. For instance, management accounting helps firms identify relevant metrics, create baselines, and quantify outcomes using established targets (Rimmel, 2020, p. 35; Baret, Songini, and Pistoni, 2022). In doing so, SDG accounting becomes a critical tool for collective action and achieving the 2030 vision.
Critical Evaluation of the Goal
Contextual Relevance
The significance of SDG 12 extends across economic, social, and environmental dimensions, highlighting the interconnected challenges faced by the global economy. SDG12 is critical because it is intricately linked to environmental problems that threaten Earth’s ecological balance. The pace of climate change, deforestation, and resource depletion has accelerated, indicating that a fundamental shift in production and consumption practices is necessary for sustainable development.
Unsustainable waste generation and resource extraction contribute substantially to extreme environmental degradation (Bianchi et al., 2023, p. 28; Thøgersen, 2023). The goal aims to mitigate the identified challenges by encouraging responsible resource management, transitioning to sustainable production, and reducing waste.
On a social level, SDG 12 intersects with crucial problems such as insufficient access to resources, inequality, and poverty. Developed economies grapple with overconsumption, which worsens resource scarcity and harms the livelihoods of people on low incomes and those living in resource-scarce areas (Heing, 2021). Since SDG 12 advocates for responsible production and consumption, it addresses social inequalities and promotes fair access to resources, potentially leading to improved well-being and poverty alleviation (Goel and Baral, 2023). Furthermore, the goal acknowledges the essence of creating a sustainable livelihood for all through ethical production methods.
Economically, unsustainable production and consumption patterns endanger long-term economic viability. The problem stems from the fact that over-reliance on inefficient production processes and finite resources can cause economic instability in the world economy. SDG 12 aligns with sustainability principles by recognizing the necessity of a circular economy.
It is crucial for its minimal waste, efficient resource use, and wealth-generating activities that support long-term social and environmental goals (Del Río et al., 2021, p. 28; Ghosh, 202). Such a transition can spur innovation, enhance resource efficiency, and create resilient economic models. In essence, SDG 12 is relevant because it has the potential to address the interconnected problems faced by the international community.
Significance Based on Targets and Indicators
The targets and indicators of SDG 12 collectively have practical implications for rethinking production and consumption practices. They offer measurable benchmarks to guide policies and evaluate progress, fostering a shift toward sustainable production. For instance, target 12.1 assesses whether national-level action plans, such as a 10-year sustainable production and consumption framework, are in place (Bernstein and Vos, 2021). Additionally, target 12.2 focuses on sustainable natural resource management, with indicators examining the material footprint and domestic material consumption (Wachowiak et al., 2023). These indicators assess raw material use and a nation’s internal resource use.
The significance of the targets and indicators lies in their ability to track and influence behavior from multinational corporations to individual consumers. For example, target 12.c focuses on removing market distortions that promote wasteful consumption (Kakar, Popovski, and Robinson, 2023). The indicator emphasizes the elimination of fossil fuel subsidies, which influences multinational firms’ behavior, as they must use greener energy sources to reduce costs.
Additionally, targets 12.3 and 12.5, which focus on halving the world’s per capita wasted food and reducing waste generation, respectively, affect individual consumers (Bernstein and Vos, 2021). They are forced to consume optimal amounts of food and to use recycling bins more (United Nations Economic and Social Council, 2020). Collectively, SDG 12’s targets and indicators influence global behaviors regarding production and consumption.
Contribution to Ethical and Sustainability Progress
SDG 12 plays a critical role in advancing sustainability and ethical objectives. In terms of ethics, the goal aligns with the principles of responsibility and justice. It acknowledges the imperative to guarantee that future and present generations have access to essential resources that facilitate a dignified life. For example, SDG 12 targets the responsible management of waste and chemicals and promotes an understanding of sustainable lifestyles (Bernstein and Vos, 2021). Thus, the goal aligns with ethical frameworks prioritizing environmental stewardship and human well-being.
SDG 12 integrates sustainability into its targets, enabling nations to track their current progress on consumption and production. For example, data shows that each person wastes about 120 kilograms of food annually, indicating that the world is off track to halve global food loss (United Nations Statistics Division, 2023). High-income countries have a higher per capita material footprint than low-income nations.
Additionally, despite efforts to phase out fossil fuels, global crises triggered an increase in their use (Sachs et al., 2021). The positives from sustainability reports include the implementation of 485 policies focusing on sustainable production and consumption shifts in the European Union and 62 other countries, as shown in Figure 1. Furthermore, company sustainability reporting has nearly tripled since 2016, whereas sustainable procurement implementation has increased by half from 2020 (United Nations Statistics Division, 2023). Although some targets seem impossible to achieve by 2030, tangible metrics enable countries to work towards improving the indicators for SDG 12, highlighting the goal’s contribution to sustainability.
Personal Opinions and Commentaries on Importance
I argue that the importance of SDG 12, centered on responsible production and consumption, resonates deeply with my beliefs, as it encapsulates the significance of sustainable living in the modern world. The goal is multifaceted, with measurable targets and indicators that reflect a holistic strategy for addressing urgent global problems. As a student, I find the emphasis on sustainable production and consumption relevant and critical to the world’s collective future.
The meticulous breakdown of the steps required to achieve SDG 12 resonates with my experiences and aligns with the values of social responsibility and environmental stewardship (Benítez-Andradeset al., 2023; Jabbour and Khan, 2022). For instance, when I walk down the street, I often encounter people on the sidewalk begging for money to feed themselves. I wonder about the food that restaurants throw away, whether due to low customer demand or if it is leftovers. Such homeless people can benefit from consumable food that is often thrown away (Hansen and Nielsen, 2022). Although such actions may sound unethical, especially when feeding hungry homeless people leftovers, such acts can save a starving person.
Evidential Application of the SDG
Evidence
The evidence will be analyzed from a country perspective, using China as an example due to its vast size and rapid development over the last 30 years. The national vision focuses on building a low-carbon, sound, and circular economic system necessary for sustainable development (Ghosh, 2020, p. 125). Notable efforts that support the desired growth strategy, guided by the principles of SDG 12, include energy conservation, water efficiency, reduction of grain loss, control of harmful substances, and green government procurement (Center for International Knowledge on Development [CIKD], 2023). Other factors may include public education and awareness, sustainable rural tourism, international cooperation, and sewage and domestic waste treatment.
China has made significant achievements in energy conservation and water efficiency. The total amount and intensity of energy use have been controlled. Although energy consumption increased by 3.2% annually since 2015, it decreased by 15.5% per RMB10,000 of gross domestic product (GDP) in 2022 (United Nations Statistics Division, 2020).
Additionally, water efficiency has improved through collaboration with key industry leaders. China’s water consumption per RMB 10,000 of GDP fell by 32.1% from 2015 to 2021 (CIKD, 2023). Furthermore, the water use per 10,000 Chinese Yuan of industrial added value decreased by 43.9% in 2021 compared to 2015 (CIKD, 2023, p. 101). These values suggest that the country is improving the efficiency of energy and water use in households and across different industries.
Furthermore, China has stepped up efforts to minimize grain losses across the entire supply chain through technological innovation, which is essential to food security. The country coordinated the control and prevention of heavy metal pollution in agricultural lands. Additionally, the safe use of polluted cultivated land was implemented by establishing monitoring points for soil quality, leading to the contaminated land use rate exceeding 90% (CIKD, 2023). The nation also increased investments in agricultural infrastructure and created more than 5,000 specialized grain centers to reduce post-harvest grain loss(CIKD, 2023). Technologies utilized for the grain centers focus on key areas such as grain monitoring, circumfluence fumigation, mechanical ventilation, and grain cooling.
The country has taken measures to control harmful substances and promote sewage and domestic waste treatment. Strict initiatives were implemented to control emissions of heavy metals, and the country exceeded targets in critical sectors. Recycling renewable resources was improved, enabling effective repackaging of waste plastics, tires, power batteries, iron, and steel. The country reprocessed 380 million tons of various renewable energy sources, while hazardous waste capacity reached approximately 170 million tons annually in 2021, as shown in Figure 2 (CIKD, 2023).
In terms of sewage and domestic waste treatment, China has introduced legislative measures, waste-free cities, and waste-sorting systems to improve waste treatment capacity. Treatment of domestic waste in urban areas reached 1.092 million tons per day in 2022, whereas sewage treatment capacity averaged 215 million cubic meters per day, reflecting a 53.4% increase from 2015 (CIKD, 2023). These numbers indicate a significant improvement in waste treatment capacity, making Chinese cities cleaner.
China has focused on rural tourism, public education and awareness, and government procurement to advance its SDG targets. The country has spent about RMB 89.98 billion on water- and energy-efficient products, with 75% of government contracts awarded to small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) (CIKD, 2023). Since the initiative’s launch, the government has lifted many people from poverty in the countryside by spending more than RMB 30 billion (CIKD, 2023).
Extensive awareness campaigns have ensured the country is aware of green living and energy-saving tips. The nation encourages rural tourism that utilizes green resources, promoting rural revitalization by employing more than 10 million people (CIKD, 2023). The numbers indicate China is on track to achieve various SDGs that enhance people’s well-being and improve the quality of life.
Contribution to SDG 12 Indicators
China’s initiatives directly contribute to achieving several SDG 12 indicators. First, strategies to minimize energy intensity and enhance water efficiency lower the material footprint indicator, indicating progress in sustainable natural resource use and management. Second, China’s efforts to mechanize grain production and reduce grain losses directly align with the food loss index (FLI) indicator and indicate that the country is progressing towards halving its per capita food waste.
Third, recycling policies, control of heavy-metal emissions, and environmentally friendly chemical management address the hazardous waste generation indicator, encouraging efficient waste management. In addition, domestic waste sorting and recycling initiatives contribute to recycling rate indicators, helping substantially reduce waste generation (Wang, Wang, and Wan, 2021, p. 165). Finally, China’s focus on green procurement aligns with the indicator emphasizing the creation of nationwide sustainable procurement plans.
Program Assessment and Outlook
China has made significant advancements in SDG 12, catalyzed by a detailed approach to accountable production and consumption. The country’s emphasis on sustainable procurement, waste reduction, and energy efficiency resonates with key indicators of SDG 12.
The theoretical basis of the progress can be explained using the ecological modernization theory. It suggests that states must collaborate with markets to protect the planet by integrating environmental problems into economic growth (Rodenbiker, 2021). Moving forward, the nation’s outlook is optimistic due to continued commitment to global SDGs (CIKD, 2023). The circular economy model reinforces the trajectory of the current success in realizing SDG 12.
Interconnection with Other SDGs
China’s devotion to SDG 12 aligns with other SDGs such as clean water and sanitation, zero hunger, life on land, life below water, and affordable and clean energy. SDG 12 emphasizes energy conservation, underscoring its contribution to clean, affordable energy goals. Additionally, China’s SDG 12 initiatives focus on recycling and industrial water efficiency, which promote clean water and sanitation.
Furthermore, SDG 12 reduces grain loss and advances agricultural sustainability in China, directly contributing to SDG 2, which targets zero hunger. Under SDG 12, China implemented strategies to improve environmental and soil quality monitoring, which impacts life on land (CIKD, 2023). Enhanced waste recycling and pollutant control indirectly promote life below water, as pollutants may adversely affect marine animals.
Criticisms and Recommendations
Opinion
China’s advancement towards responsible production and consumption, as outlined in SDG 12, faces multiple criticisms that warrant close attention. A grave concern is the recurring issue of overproduction, which can jeopardize trade relations with partners and rivals alike. Overproduction occurs when demand for products in the Chinese and global markets decreases, leaving companies with massive inventories. To clear inventory, they can export to other countries if the domestic market cannot buy all the finished goods (Dreher et al., 2022).
However, the practice, if done consistently, can cause a significant challenge in excessive waste generation in most industries, including fashion and steel. As a result, the global economy may be left with surpluses that adversely impact waste management systems (Swain and Sweet, 2021). This means that while China may achieve its targets for SDG 12 domestically, it can lead to increased global waste from inefficient production patterns, exacerbating environmental degradation.
Policy implementation and gaps are critical issues in SDG 12 initiatives, given differences in success across geographies. Top-tier cities are more likely to have robust systems for managing sustainable production and consumption compared to lower-tier cities. The challenge may arise from inconsistencies in local-level implementation despite well-designed sustainability policies (Hamdan et al., 2023). The decentralized approach is necessary due to China’s vast size; however, it may lead to varied enforcement and interpretation, hampering uniform progress on SDG 12. Additionally, the rapid pace of industrialization can take a toll on ecosystems, especially in the mining of critical minerals.
Furthermore, the management of electronic waste is a pressing issue for China due to the growing middle class, underscoring the need for further investment in efficient e-waste disposal. Informal electronic waste recyclers often resort to unsustainable methods, which further burden ecosystems (Schneider and Zeng, 2022, p. 7). Policy gaps in this area and for specific appliances indicate the war on electronic waste will continue.
Suggestions
China can consider several options to optimize its response to challenges that impede achieving SDG 12 targets. First, the nation can recalibrate economic incentives by continuing to implement circular economic principles. Such strategies can reduce overproduction and incentivize firms to adopt responsible production methods (Bhalla, 2021, p. 72).
Additionally, the government should continually assess whether current improvements are successful across all industries. Production quotas and targets for waste reduction across sectors and companies can help build a green economy (Liu and Ramakrishna, 2021). Penalties should be imposed for non-compliance, and rewards should be awarded to those who exceed targets.
Second, China can incentivize electronic waste management and include regulations for the informal sector and manufacturers. Businesses should be encouraged to utilize lean production and invest in eco-friendly technologies to minimize waste. Furthermore, electronic waste management systems should involve collection points, incentivized recycling in the formal and informal sectors, and enforcement of effective disposal methods (Kandasamy, Sakthivel, and Davim, 2023, p. 92). Collaboration with technology manufacturers to design recyclable products is a critical step in China’s next step in achieving SDG 12.
Conclusion
An analysis of SDG 12 reveals that recent global crises and implementation challenges are hindering its achievement. SDGs as a whole are critical to creating sustainable ecosystems where future generations can live with access to essential resources. SGDs are crucial because they provide a measurable path to sustainable progress. The exploration delved into China’s specific actions to achieve SDG 12, illustrating its progress in reducing waste, raising awareness, and improving resource efficiency, underscoring its commitment to the goal.
However, persistent challenges in policy gaps and overproduction may impede the country’s future progress. The country must learn to avoid overproduction at the expense of reduced export output. The issue is critical since it is directly related to economic development. The government must align economic incentives across all sectors to avoid uneven progress and promote standardized oversight (Biggeri et al., 2023, p. 450). A collaborative approach is necessary if China is to advance SDG 12 while balancing environmental stewardship and economic growth.
The aspirations summarized in SDG 12 aim for responsible production and consumption and are indispensable and ambitious. The goal’s importance aligns with the need to harmonize environmental sustainability with economic progress, a challenging task given the complexity of consumption patterns and global economies. The indicators and targets, rooted in sustainable management, waste reduction, and resource efficiency, are sound in theory. However, their achievability before 2030 depends on the combined efforts of individuals, industries, and nations.
A significant challenge is the difference in implementation in developing and developed nations. Due to this problem, the goal cannot be achieved globally by 2030, although individual nations can accomplish all their SDG 12 targets (Popescu, 2021; Birdthistle and Hales, 2023). Other challenges may include overproduction and existing consumption patterns that are hard to change. While China and other world economies have made considerable progress in SDG 12, a more innovative and collaborative approach is critical to realizing such ambitions by 2030.
Reference List
Baret, P., Songini, L. and Pistoni, A. (eds.) (2022) Sustainability accounting, management control and reporting: A European perspective. New York, NY: Routledge.
Bebbington, J. et al. (eds.) (2023) Routledge handbook of environmental accounting. New York, NY: Routledge.
Bebbington, J., Unerman, J. and O’Dwyer, B. (2014) Sustainability accounting and accountability. 2nd edn. London: Routledge.
Benítez-Andrades, J.A. et al. (eds.) (2023) Global challenges for a sustainable society: Eureca-Pro the European University for responsible consumption and production. Cham: Springer Nature.
Bernstein, J.M. and Vos, R.O. (2021) SDG12 – Sustainable consumption and production: A revolutionary challenge for the 21st century. Bingley: Emerald Group Publishing.
Bhalla, S.G. (2021) Circular economy- (Re) emerging movement. Gurugram: Invincible Publishers.
Bianchi, E.C. et al. (eds.) (2023) Responsible consumption and sustainability: Case studies from corporate social responsibility, social marketing, and behavioral economics. Cham: Springer Nature.
Biggeri, M. et al. (2023) ‘China’s subnational policies and the performance of provinces towards meeting the UN’s sustainable development goals,’ Regional Studies, Regional Science, 10(1), pp. 439–460.
Birdthistle, N. and Hales, R. (eds.) (2023) Attaining the 2030 sustainable development goal of responsible consumption and production. Bingley: Emerald Publishing Limited.
Center for International Knowledge on Development (2023) China’s progress report on implementation of the 2030 agenda for sustainable development.
Crane, A. et al. (2019) Business ethics: Managing corporate citizenship and sustainability in the age of globalization. 5th edn. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Del Río, P. et al. (2021) The Circular economy: Economic, managerial and policy implications. Cham: Springer Nature.
Dreher, A.et al. (2022). Banking on Beijing: The aims and impacts of China’s overseas development program. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ghosh, S.K. (2020) Circular economy: Global perspective. Cham: Springer Nature.
Goel, R. and Baral, S.K. (2023) Handbook of research on sustainable consumption and production for greener economies. Hershey: IGI Global.
Hamdan, M. et al. (eds.) (2023) Public policy’s role in achieving sustainable development goals. Hershey: IGI Global.
Hansen, A. and Nielsen, K.B. (eds.) (2022) Consumption, sustainability and everyday life. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Heing, B. (ed.) (2021) Sustainable consumption. New York, NY: Greenhaven Publishing LLC.
Jabbour, C.J.C. and Khan, S.A.R. (eds.) (2022) Sustainable production and consumption systems. Bugis: Springer.
Kakar, N., Popovski, V. and Robinson, N.A. (eds.) (2023) Fulfilling the sustainable development goals: On a quest for a sustainable future. New York, NY: Routledge.
Kandasamy, J., Sakthivel, A.R. and Davim, J.P. (eds.) (2023) Progress in sustainable manufacturing. Bugis: Springer Nature.
Laine, M., Tregidga, H. and Unerman, J. (eds.) (2021) Sustainability accounting and accountability. New York, NY: Routledge.
Liu, L. and Ramakrishna, S. (2021) An Introduction to circular economy. Cham: Springer.
Popescu, C.R.G. (2021) Handbook of research on novel practices and current successes in achieving the sustainable development goals. Hershey: IGI Global.
Popescu, C.R.G. (2022) Positive and constructive contributions for sustainable development goals. Hershey: IGI Global.
Rimmel, G. (ed.) (2020) Accounting for sustainability. New York, NY: Routledge.
Rodenbiker, J. (2021) ‘Making ecology developmental: China’s environmental sciences and green modernization in global context,’ Annals of the American Association of Geographers, 111(7), pp. 1–18.
Sachs, J. et al. (2021) Sustainable development report 2020: The sustainable development goals and COVID-19 includes the SDG index and dashboards. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Schneider, A.F. and Zeng, X. (2022) ‘Investigations into the transition toward an established e-waste management system in China: Empirical evidence from Guangdong and Shaanxi,’ Current Research in Environmental Sustainability, 4, pp. 1-10.
Swain, R.B. and Sweet, S. (eds.) (2021) Sustainable consumption and production, volume i: Challenges and development. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Thøgersen, J. (2023) Concise introduction to sustainable consumption. Northampton: Edward Elgar Publishing.
United Nations Economic and Social Council (2020) Report of the inter-agency and expert group on sustainable development goal indicators.
United Nations Statistics Division (2020) The sustainable development goals report 2020.
United Nations Statistics Division (2023) The sustainable development goals report 2023: special edition towards a rescue plan for people and planet.
Wachowiak, P. et al. (eds.) (2023) Responsible management and sustainable consumption: Creating a consumer and enterprise social responsibility index. New York, NY: Routledge.
Wang, J., Wang, X. and Wan, J. (eds.) (2021) Environmental strategy and planning in China. Bugis: Springer Nature.