Introduction
Race and racism have remained an emotive issue in the United States, as persons of color feel equality has not been achieved. At the same time, the white population perceives that they have ceded enough ground. However, unlike in the current reality, where specific steps are being taken to increase diversity and representation, little was done to challenge covert discrimination and prejudice against persons of color in the twentieth century. In most sectors of society, including but not limited to the arts, negative perceptions and stereotypes of persons of color persisted.
Stereotypical Portrayal of Persons of Color
In The Black Musical, James Leve discusses the persistent portrayal of negative stereotypes of persons of color (POC) in Broadway productions throughout the twentieth century. In particular, Levi (2016) notes that POC was portrayed as “thoughtless, shuffling, superstitious, devious, and servile” (320). Leve notes that these stereotypes were deeply ingrained in the consciousness of white America and endured for a long time. His focus on this topic sharpens attention to Broadway’s role in perpetuating or challenging these harmful stereotypes in the context of music theater.
The Broadways has played a significant role in perpetuating bias and prejudice against persons of color with many productions either reflecting or reinforcing such stereotypes. One of the most common examples of this is the portrayal of African Americans in early musicals. For these productions, African Americans were depicted as caricatures or comic relief, which reinforced the stereotype of black inferiority and subservience.
For example, in the musical Hairspray, despite the narrative challenging racial segregation, certain characters, such as Motormouth Maybelle and Seaweed, were initially portrayed in stereotypical ways. Their portrayal not only misrepresents the lived experience of persons of color, but they also contribute to the reinforcement of racist attitudes and negative perceptions of Black people among the audience.
Additionally, Broadway has contributed to the continued marginalization of POC by relegating them to stereotypical roles or limiting their artistic expression in favor of white performers. This practice has not only reinforced the notion of white supremacy but has also deprived POC of representation and the opportunity to showcase their craft to the world. However, there are notable instances when Broadway, especially musical productions, have done their level best to counter stereotypes and promote the representation of POC.
For instance, in Hairspray, despite the initiative to portray stereotypes, the narrative develops in a way that allows characters such as Motormouth Maybelle to emerge and be empowered, becoming champions in the fight against injustice and discrimination. The resilience and determination of these characters significantly shape the show’s overall message, promoting racial equality and acceptance of one another regardless of skin color.
Similarly, the musical West Side Story contributes to the challenging of negative stereotypes related to POC. Specifically, while the characters of Jet and Sharks initially embody negative stereotypes prevalent in Broadway musicals, their exploration of themes such as prejudice and identity is more complex than typical portrayals. This musical, with its deep inquiry into the socio-economic factors that lead to gang violence, the challenges that immigrant communities face, and the humanization of the characters, contributes to a better understanding of the context of the many problems that POC communities face. Thus, while Broadway musicals have generally promoted negative stereotypes, there are notable instances in which they have subverted them and presented a more realistic picture of people of color, contributing to greater, more positive stage representation.
The White Perspective and the Fight for Racial Equality
Representation in the entertainment industry has remained a contentious issue for a long time. The assertion by composer Virgil Thompson that folklore subjects by an outsider remain valid as long as the subject is unable to speak for themselves, which was not the case for the African American in 1935, is interesting in many respects (Kostelanetz, 2013, p. 151). Firstly, this statement prompts the issue of the representation of non-white ethnic minority groups in musicals.
The sentiments of this composer are relevant to the production of musicals such as West Side Story, Carmen Jones, and Hairspray. Despite featuring a mixed cast, these musicals were created and produced by entirely white teams. As such, this reality naturally leads to the question of whether the “white perspective” in these musicals is detrimental and beneficial to the fight for racial equality.
One perspective on this issue is that the involvement of primarily white creatives in these musicals presents an opportunity for cross-cultural understanding and empathy among the audiences. This is achieved by translating and contextualizing the experience of POC for a predominantly white audience, which increases awareness and engagement on issues such as racism and discrimination. On the other hand, the absolute dominance of white people in the creative process raises concerns about the authenticity and accuracy of POC experiences.
Without lived experiences and first-hand knowledge, a predominantly white creative team would be inherently incapable of portraying anything close to the reality that persons of color face each day. As such, the content produced ends up reinforcing negative stereotypes and narratives of racial superiority and inferiority. This is especially prevalent in instances when creators appropriate cultural elements and reduce them to mere tropes and caricatures.
Additionally, this lack of representation on production teams raises concerns about tokenism and the equitable distribution of opportunities in the entertainment industry. While one can argue that the lack of opportunities for POC is a historically systemic issue, this argument does not absolve the industry of the responsibility to promote diversity and inclusion in all aspects of Broadway productions. Thus, while the involvement of white creators on pertinent issues revolving around POC, it is imperative to maintain a level of authenticity that all audiences can relate to and promote equitable opportunities for all artists without promoting negative narratives that reinforce stereotypes and prejudice.
Therefore, in the spirit of equality, representation, authenticity, and inclusion, the entertainment industry must always ensure that minority voices are heard. Such practice is especially important when the material being prepared concerns them. A white perspective on POC issues may be helpful in certain contexts, but priority should be given to individuals with actual lived experiences.
Romantic Era Operatic Music versus World War II-era American South
The adaptation of the romantic-era opera Carmen by Georges Bizet into Carmen Jones is intriguing from the standpoint of cultural translation and reinterpretation. In particular, Carman Jones, set in the World War II-era American South, reimagines the story and characters through Bizet’s music to tell a uniquely American narrative. As such, the romantic music composed for the French audience transforms, infused with elements of jazz, blues, and gospel to reflect the cultural context of the American South. This reinterpretation of an old classic revitalizes it and makes it available and relevant to a vastly wider audience than its original one. It also makes the music resonate with the audience accustomed to African American musical traditions.
However, despite the cultural and temporal differences, Carmen and Carman Jones share certain thematic similarities. In particular, they both explore the themes of love, jealousy, and fate. However, Carman Jones explores these themes through the lens of an African American’s life, offering a unique perspective on World War II America. In addition, the tragic trajectory of Care, marked by defiance and desire, transcends cultural boundaries, making the musical resonate with audiences across generations. Therefore, despite the changes to the original Carmen to fit the African American context during the Second World War, the underlying themes remain critical to both works, reflecting the universality of this tragic story.
Conclusion
Therefore, Broadway’s musicals, especially in the 20th century, perpetuated negative stereotypes against people of color, while others made subtle but significant steps to promote diversity and inclusion. James Leve highlights this assertion in The Black Musical, noting that negative stereotypes about people of color were persistent in 20th-century musicals. Similarly, creative teams in musicals such as West Side Story, Hairspray, and Carmen Jones raise questions about the promotion of predominantly white narratives to tell stories about POC. However, despite the challenges, the adoption of the romantic-era musical Carmen in a World War II African American context demonstrates the potential for reimagining classics. As Broadway continues to evolve, it must ensure that the voices of the majority and the minority are equally represented and heard in all aspects.
References
Kostelanetz, R. (2013). Virgil Thomson A Reader: Selected Writings, 1924-1984. Routledge.
Leve, J. (2016). American musical theater. Oxford University Press.